Paper 2017/977 Original: eprint.iacr.org/2017/977 ↗

Cryptanalysis against Symmetric-Key Schemes with Online Classical Queries and Offline Quantum Computations

Abstract

In this paper, quantum attacks against symmetric-key schemes are presented in which adversaries only make classical queries but use quantum computers for offline computations. Our attacks are not as efficient as polynomial-time attacks making quantum superposition queries, while our attacks use the realistic model and overwhelmingly improve the classical attacks. Our attacks convert a type of classical meet-in-the-middle attacks into quantum ones. The attack cost depends on the number of available qubits and the way to realize the quantum hardware. The tradeoff between data complexity $D$ and time complexity $T$ against the problem of cardinality $N$ is $D^2 \cdot T^2 =N$ and $D \cdot T^6 = N^3$ in the best and worst case scenarios to the adversary respectively, while the classic attack requires $D\cdot T = N$. This improvement is meaningful from an engineering aspect because several existing schemes claim beyond-birthday-bound security for $T$ by limiting the maximum $D$ to be below $2^{n/2}$ according to the classical tradeoff $D\cdot T = N$. Those schemes are broken if quantum offline computations are performed by adversaries. The attack can be applied to many schemes such as a tweakable block-cipher construction TDR, a dedicated MAC scheme Chaskey, an on-line authenticated encryption scheme McOE-X, a hash function based MAC H$^2$-MAC and a permutation based MAC keyed-sponge. The idea is then applied to the FX-construction to discover new tradeoffs in the classical query model.