Paper 2025/975 Original: eprint.iacr.org/2025/975 ↗

Incompressible Encryption with Everlasting Security

Abstract

Recently, the concept of incompressible encryption has emerged as a powerful enhancement to key-leakage resilience. In an incompressible encryption scheme, an adversary who intercepts ciphertexts is forced to dedicate a significant amount of memory to store them in full if they wish to extract any information about the plaintext later when the secret key becomes available. Given two messages, the security game involves two adversaries: the first adversary receives an encryption of one of the messages and produces a compressed state. Then, the second adversary, given both the secret key and the compressed state, attempts to determine which message was encrypted. Several positive results exist in incompressible cryptography. On the one hand, there are constructions based on minimal assumptions but with a poor rate (i.e., rate tends to 0). On the other hand, there are rate-1 constructions that achieve optimal efficiency but rely on strong cryptographic assumptions, such as obfuscation. A stronger security notion, known as everlasting security, has been proposed for incompressible encryption. In this formulation, the second adversary, who receives the compressed state and the secret key, is allowed to be computationally unbounded. While this notion is conceptually appealing, no constructions of everlasting incompressible encryption are currently known, regardless of the underlying assumption or even in idealized models. In this work, we give the first construction of everlasting incompressible encryption. In fact, we show that everlasting incompressible encryption is inherent in any sufficiently secure public-key encryption scheme. Specifically, we prove that any public-key encryption scheme with subexponential security (when instantiated with an appropriate security parameter) already satisfies the definition of everlasting incompressible encryption with subexponential security. Furthermore, our scheme achieves rate-1, improving upon existing results even for the weaker notion of standard incompressible encryption. Our results raise concerns about whether the current definition of incompressible encryption adequately captures the expected efficiency properties of such schemes, indicating that refinements may be needed. As one concrete step in this direction, we propose a storage-rate definition for ciphertexts, and show how to construct schemes with constant storage-rate.